By Sam Ben-Meir*
NEW YORK | 18 November 2026 (IDN) — Andrew Patterson’s The Rivals of Amziah King (2026) appears at first to be a story about competition, community, and revenge. But beneath its exuberant musical performances, eccentric characters, and increasingly violent confrontations lies a more radical philosophical proposition: that human beings are capable of organizing their lives according to principles fundamentally different from those governing capitalist exchange. The film’s recurring images of honeybee colonies are crucial to this vision, as are its extraordinary scenes of communal music-making. Together, they suggest a conception of freedom that is neither individualistic nor hierarchical, but realized through relationships of mutual dependence, responsiveness, and care.
The film follows Amziah King (Matthew McConaughey), an Oklahoma beekeeper, musician, and unlikely patriarch whose small honey-producing enterprise sustains a community of friends, workers, and assorted misfits. When Kateri (Angelina LookingGlass), a young woman who once lived with Amziah and his late wife as a foster child, returns to his life, she is welcomed into a world whose organizing principles seem almost anachronistic. People work together, eat together, make music together, and assume responsibilities for one another that cannot be reduced to contractual obligations. Their relationships are not without tensions, but they are sustained by something other than the pursuit of individual advantage.
The title announces the central conflict: Amziah King has rivals, and their rivalry will eventually threaten the world he has built. Yet the opposition between competition and cooperation, while unmistakable, does not exhaust the film’s meaning. Nor does the revenge narrative that increasingly dominates its second half. Patterson is interested in something more fundamental: what it means to belong to a community, and whether the freedom we seek might depend upon precisely those relationships that modern economic life encourages us to regard as limitations upon our independence.
The life of the hive
The honeybee colony offers a revealing point of departure. We ordinarily imagine the hive as a miniature monarchy, governed by a queen whose subjects perform their assigned duties in unquestioning obedience. But as the biologist Thomas D. Seeley demonstrates in his remarkable book Honeybee Democracy (2010), this picture is profoundly misleading. The queen is indispensable to the reproductive life of the colony, but she does not command its activities. The complex organization of the hive emerges largely through the decentralized interactions of worker bees, whose collective intelligence enables them to respond to changing circumstances without direction from a sovereign authority.
Seeley’s most striking research concerns the process by which swarming honeybees select a new home. Scout bees investigate potential nesting sites, communicate their discoveries through elaborate dances, and participate in a collective process through which competing possibilities are evaluated. No single bee possesses a complete picture of the available alternatives. Through communication, responsiveness, and the gradual formation of consensus, the colony achieves a result that exceeds the capacities of any individual member. This decentralized organization extends beyond the selection of a new home. As Seeley observes, “the queen mother is not the workers’ boss. Indeed, there is no all-knowing central planner supervising the thousands and thousands of worker bees in a colony. The work of a hive is instead governed collectively by the workers themselves…”
This is not democracy in the human political sense, nor should the biological organization of insects be treated as a blueprint for human society. Honeybees are not citizens deliberating about justice, and their cooperative behavior is shaped by evolutionary processes that differ fundamentally from the historical and ethical dimensions of human freedom. Nature cannot tell us how we ought to organize our economic institutions. Nevertheless, Seeley’s research unsettles a deeply entrenched assumption: that complex social coordination necessarily requires hierarchical command, or that collective intelligence must be concentrated in a privileged individual.
The irony of Patterson’s title becomes particularly suggestive in this light. Amziah King presides over a community, but his authority is not fundamentally sovereign. He does not govern through coercion, nor does he seek to reduce those around him to instruments of his will. His influence derives from his ability to cultivate relationships, recognize the capacities of others, and sustain a common world in which those capacities can flourish. His authority is exercised not to secure their subordination, but to make possible their eventual independence. When he explains the organization of the hive to Kateri, including the replacement of its queen, the lesson echoes the principle illustrated by Seeley’s research into collective nest-site selection: the colony’s organization does not depend upon the commands of a sovereign. The colony must be capable of continuing beyond the individual around whom its life has been organized.
Freedom through music
Yet the most compelling expression of this alternative social existence is found not among the bees but in the music. Patterson repeatedly interrupts the forward movement of the narrative with extended musical performances. Amziah and his companions gather with their instruments, exchanging melodies, accompanying one another, and entering into the spontaneous give-and-take of collective performance. These scenes are more than celebrations of regional musical culture, and they are certainly more than decorative interludes. They allow us to witness a form of freedom that cannot be understood as the unrestricted assertion of individual will.
Consider what happens when musicians play together. Each performer brings distinctive abilities, sensibilities, and intentions to the encounter. Yet none can realize those capacities independently of the others. The guitarist must listen to the mandolin, the singer must respond to the rhythm, and each musician must remain attentive to possibilities that emerge only in the course of the performance. Individual expression is not sacrificed to the collective; rather, it becomes possible through participation in a shared activity. The freedom of each musician is enlarged by the freedom of the others.
The philosopher Bruce Ellis Benson develops a particularly illuminating account of this phenomenon in The Improvisation of Musical Dialogue: A Phenomenology of Music (2003). Challenging the conventional separation between composition and performance, Benson argues that musical activity is fundamentally improvisational. Even when musicians perform an established composition, they do not merely reproduce a fixed object. They interpret, respond, anticipate, and contribute to an unfolding dialogue whose meaning cannot be exhausted by the intentions of any single participant. Music, on this account, is not simply a product created by an isolated subject. It is an event that takes place among participants, including composers, performers, and listeners, whose contributions enter into relationships of mutual responsiveness. The musical work is continually renewed through the activity of those who bring it into being.
This conception helps illuminate what Patterson accomplishes through the film’s musical sequences. The musicians are not simply individuals cooperating to produce an agreeable sound. They are engaged in an activity in which freedom takes the form of responsiveness to others. To listen is not to surrender one’s autonomy; it is to enter into the conditions through which meaningful expression becomes possible. The musician who refuses to listen, who insists upon dominating the performance, destroys the very relationships that make the music possible.
Here the film approaches a conception of freedom fundamentally at odds with the individualism that dominates modern economic ideology. Freedom is commonly identified with independence, with the capacity to pursue one’s preferences without interference from others. Social relationships consequently appear as external constraints upon an otherwise self-sufficient individual. But musical activity reveals the poverty of this conception. The freedom of the musician does not precede the relationships through which music is made. It emerges within them. The same principle governs Amziah’s community. Its members are not interchangeable units whose value can be measured solely by their economic productivity. They possess distinctive capacities, histories, and vulnerabilities, and their participation in a common life allows those differences to become sources of mutual enrichment. The community does not abolish individuality. It provides the conditions under which individuality can acquire meaning.
Cooperation and capital
This is where Marx becomes indispensable to understanding the film’s deeper political significance. For Marx, capitalism is not simply an economic system that rewards selfishness or encourages excessive competition. It is a historically specific organization of social relations in which human labor and the products of collective activity assume the form of commodities. Relationships among people are increasingly mediated by relationships among things, while the cooperative powers of society confront individuals as forces beyond their control.
In Capital, Marx describes how the social character of human labor becomes obscured through commodity fetishism. The relations connecting producers appear as relations between the commodities they exchange. What is fundamentally a network of human interdependence assumes the appearance of an impersonal system governed by the movement of prices, property, and capital. The consequences extend beyond the marketplace. When economic life is organized around accumulation and competitive advantage, the relationships through which people sustain one another become subordinate to imperatives they do not collectively determine.
Cooperation does not disappear under capitalism; indeed, capitalist production depends upon it. But cooperation is organized under conditions in which its purposes and benefits are often controlled by those who own the means of production. The decisive question, then, is not whether people cooperate, but whether they exercise meaningful control over the purposes of their cooperation. Collective activity does not become emancipatory merely because individuals work together. What matters is whether they participate in determining the ends toward which their shared capacities are directed.
The conflict between Amziah and the agricultural interests represented by Dob McCoy (Kurt Russell) dramatizes this contradiction. Both men participate in commercial activity, and Amziah’s honey enterprise is hardly situated outside the market. The film does not imagine a world without production, exchange, or economic necessity. What distinguishes Amziah’s community is the refusal to make accumulation the ultimate measure of human relationships. For McCoy, economic power becomes inseparable from domination. For Amziah, productive activity remains embedded in relationships of loyalty, apprenticeship, friendship, and mutual obligation. Honey is a commodity, but the community that produces it is not reducible to the commodity form. Its members are bound together by practices whose value cannot be adequately expressed in monetary terms.
This distinction is essential. The film does not suggest that capitalism can be overcome through kindness alone, nor that small businesses are inherently more humane than large corporations. Amziah’s world remains vulnerable precisely because it exists within a broader economic order governed by forces it cannot fully control. Its survival depends upon relationships that the logic of competition continually threatens to dissolve. The contrast between the hive and the market should therefore not be understood as an opposition between nature and society, as though the former possessed an innocence that the latter has lost. Rather, the colony makes visible a possibility that capitalist ideology tends to obscure: that coordination need not be imposed from above, and that the flourishing of a collective need not require the subordination of its members to an external power.
Music takes this insight further. Unlike the biological coordination of bees, musical performance involves interpretation, imagination, and the conscious transformation of inherited practices. It offers not a natural model to imitate but a human experience through which an alternative conception of freedom becomes palpable. What the hive suggests about collective organization, music reveals about the lived experience of being together.
Kateri comes into her own
Kateri’s emergence as the film’s central figure brings these themes into sharper focus. Having experienced abandonment and instability, she initially approaches the world with understandable suspicion. Her return to Amziah is not simply a homecoming but an entry into relationships that allow her to recover capacities long constrained by the struggle for survival. Through work, music, and participation in communal life, she becomes capable of inhabiting a world that is no longer defined exclusively by loss. Her development also complicates the film’s conception of freedom. Kateri is not merely rescued by a benevolent patriarch; she becomes an agent in her own right, capable of assuming responsibility for the community and determining its future. This is the decisive test of Amziah’s authority. If the community merely reproduced his will, it would remain dependent upon the very form of sovereignty that his example seems to challenge. The movement from Amziah to Kateri is therefore not simply a transfer of authority from one individual to another. It reveals that the strength of a community resides in its capacity to cultivate the independence of its members and sustain relationships through which they become capable not merely of preserving a common world, but of transforming it.
The limits of solidarity
Yet Patterson refuses to make this vision entirely consoling. The film’s descent into violence raises a troubling question: can a community founded upon mutual care defend itself without adopting the methods of those who threaten it? Kateri’s revenge is emotionally intelligible, but it also introduces a tension between the community’s affirmative principles and the destructive means through which its survival is secured.
The bee colony offers no easy resolution. Honeybees cooperate with extraordinary sophistication, but they also defend their colony against perceived threats. Collective solidarity does not necessarily entail universal concern, and the existence of cooperative relationships within a group tells us little, by itself, about how that group will treat outsiders. A community is not emancipatory simply because its members cooperate. What matters is whether their relationships enlarge their capacities for freedom, including their ability to recognize and respond to those beyond the boundaries of their own community. This is another reason to resist treating the hive as a direct model for human social organization. Human freedom requires more than effective coordination or loyalty to one’s own community. It involves the capacity to question the boundaries of belonging, to recognize obligations extending beyond established relationships, and to transform the social conditions under which violence becomes necessary.
The film’s revenge narrative thus exposes a difficulty that its musical performances momentarily overcome. In music, the responsiveness of each participant enlarges the possibilities available to the others. In revenge, the assertion of agency threatens to become inseparable from the destruction of another. The two forms of action coexist uneasily within the film, and their tension should not be dissolved into a simple moral lesson. What remains most compelling about The Rivals of Amziah King is its insistence that another way of being together is possible. Its vision is neither a detailed political program nor a sentimental retreat into an imagined past. It emerges through concrete practices: preparing food, tending bees, sharing knowledge, welcoming strangers, and making music. These activities disclose a world in which the individual is not diminished by belonging but becomes more fully capable through relationships with others.
Marx understood that human emancipation could not consist merely in liberating isolated individuals to pursue their private interests. It required transforming the social relations through which their collective powers were organized and controlled. Benson’s phenomenology of musical dialogue helps us understand what such freedom might feel like from within: not the absence of dependence, but participation in relationships that make creativity, responsiveness, and self-expression possible. And Seeley’s honeybees remind us that even in the natural world, remarkable forms of collective intelligence can arise without a sovereign directing every movement.
The deepest irony of Patterson’s film may therefore lie in the name of its protagonist. Amziah King is most successful not when he exercises authority over his community, but when he makes himself dispensable to its continued existence. What survives is not the sovereignty of the king but the relationships he helped bring into being. The rivals of Amziah King may compete for wealth, territory, and power. But the world he cultivates is organized around something they cannot possess through competition alone: the capacity to create a common life. And perhaps the film’s most radical suggestion is that freedom, like music, is not something we possess in isolation. It is something we make together.
*Sam Ben-Meir teaches philosophy at the City University of New York, College of Technology. He is the author of Ethical Interanimality: Toward a Relational Philosophy of Nature (Westphalia Press, 2026). (IDN-InDepthNews)

