Viewpoint by Manish Uprety F.R.A.S. and Jainendra Karn
Manish Uprety is an ex-diplomat & ALCAP’s Special Adviser for Asia & Africa and Jainendra Karn is a senior leader of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Any views or opinions expressed are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of IDN-InDepth News.
New Delhi (IDN) — The SAARC Foreign Minister’s Meet scheduled for 25 September 2021 in New York was cancelled as Pakistan insisted that the Taliban government rather than the representatives of the previous Afghan government should be allowed to participate.
Interestingly, the Taliban nominated their Doha based spokesman Suhail Shaheen as Afghanistan’s UN ambassador and asked to speak at the United Nations. Countries like Qatar and Pakistan now urge the world to engage with the Taliban.
While one tries to comprehend why Americans handed Afghanistan to the Taliban on a platter, one even tries even more to figure out which side the dice will turn as Iacta alea est in the great game called Afghanistan.
The field of international relations is such that it gives one a chance to interact with, assess individuals and frameworks that play an important role in the developments that affect us. And of course, the feelings are a mixed bag of emotions and admiration.
For example, wisdom dawned after a heavy evening in the United Nations Delegate’s lounge about the legend of Henry Kissinger and the influence on US foreign policy. One finally concluded that even though Kissinger might have meant business, the myth of Henry Kissinger is actually a myth.
On the other hand, being on an advisory board along with Dr. Thomas P M Barnett introduced one to the wonderful academic frameworks of “the Functioning Core” and the “Non-Integrating Gap” to understand our world and make a sense of it.
It is a geopolitical theory that looks at the world through a binary. It came into prominence in the year 2003 during the invasion of Iraq when Thomas wrote an article in support of the military action entitled “The Pentagon’s New Map.”
In a nutshell, the central thesis of geopolitical theory is that in the Functioning Core of the world, the connections globalization brings between countries (including network connectivity, financial transactions, and media flows) are synonymous with those countries with stable governments, rising standards of living, and “more deaths by suicide than by murder”.
Whereas the areas that make up the Non-Integrating Gap are the ones where globalization has not yet penetrated, and which are synonymous with political repression, poverty, disease, and mass-murder, and conflict.
Therefore, the United States must “export security” to the Gap in order to integrate and connect those regions with the Core, even if this means going to war in Gap countries, followed by long periods of nation-building.
Afghanistan is a classic case that one can interpret as an example of US action that was supposedly undertaken to integrate and connect the typical Non-Integrating Gap that the country is.
However, Democrat Congresswoman and former US Presidential candidate Tulsi Gabbard who later supported the current US President Jo Biden deemed the US’ mission in Afghanistan as ‘unnecessary’ and ‘wasteful.’
She criticised the American elite of lacking any clear mission or strategy after the swift defeat of Al-Qaeda in Afghanistan. The decisions of the leadership or the lack of it caused a lot of suffering along with wasting the US taxpayer’s money worth Trillions.
The manner in which the US left Afghanistan is also construed as a betrayal of the country by the Americans. Under peace envoy Zalmay Khalilzad, better known for his pro-Pakistan policies, the U.S. Administration gave away everything America has fought for in Afghanistan since 9/11.
Looking back, it was actually Kissinger’s protégé, Zbigniew Brzezinski, who was the person behind the US’ wrong decision to intervene in Afghanistan. The US laid the foundations of its defeat in Afghanistan of 2021 way back in 1979 itself.
The intervention sowed the seeds of Islamic terrorism in the region and the US then paid the huge price for that mistake on 9/11. Strangely Taliban now claims that there is “No Proof” that Osama bin Laden was ever involved in the 9/11 attack on the US.
What if there is another repeat of 9/11? The flight of the US from Afghanistan has cast a doubt on its leadership. It shows that the West will never stand up to fight for its values. It seems to have lost the will to fight.
The deep links of Pakistan in the US and also in Afghanistan are well known. Syed Ghulam Nabi Fai, a front for Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) in the US who used to lobby with the policymakers, was arrested by the FBI in 2011.
Whether it was Pakistani Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the perpetrator of 9/11 or Osama bin Laden of Al-Qaeda who was found next to a military complex in Abbotabad, Pakistan, the country has much sway in the region.
Terrorism’s effects are not only without but also within. In 2020, the FBI helped India in tracking the masterminds of the Pulwama terror attack which were located in Pakistan.
Is it not very surprising that 70-75 thousand Taliban who seem from the medieval times defeated a supposedly modern, trained and equipped by the West, Afghan army of over 3 million?
Pakistan’s involvement in harbouring the Taliban and Haqqani Network is also under America’s scanner. Anthony Blinken has mentioned that US will reassess its ties with Pakistan over Afghanistan future.
What is not a common knowledge is that the fountain head of Taliban is actually Darul Uloom Deoband which is an Islamic seminary in Deoband, India. Deobandi is an Islamic revivalist movement within Sunni, primarily Hanafi, Islam.
Its political wing Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind which was formed in 1919 played a major role in communalizing and polarizing the Muslims in India. Through the organisations such as Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind and Tablighi Jamaat the Deoband Madrassah Movement began to spread and is now not only in South Asia but also throughout the world.
Buoyed by Taliban’s victory of Kabul, Ayesha Siddiqa, a scholar of South Asia notes that Jaish-e-Mohammed, a Pakistan-based Deobandi Jihadist Mujahedeen group now wants to target Kashmir in India. Given Taliban’s much reiterated hostility towards India, after the USSR and US, now it is India’s turn to face the music.
What is curious is that like many across the world, a few in India, world’s largest democracy, such as the Peace Party whose stance on key issues has almost always been Islamist, welcome the takeover of Afghanistan by the Taliban.
Every country in the world including India, Russia and China face the same problems while dealing with terrorism at home which is about militants integrating into global networks. This makes the countries in the neighbourhood of Afghanistan particularly vulnerable to Islamic terrorism.
However there are some indifferent perspectives of Realpolitik who want to get over it all and move on with their lives like before, such as Professor Yiwei of China who claimed that the Taliban are the ‘Liberation Army’ of Afghanistan who “are demonized by the U.S., but are China’s ‘Good Brothers.’
One has to understand that the field of international relations is very obfuscating where states are involved in the game for various reasons. They undertake various initiatives such as initiation, involvement, rescue, abandonment etc. that are in synergy with their priorities.
For example, according to the US Cables, Sweden wanted to bomb Afghanistan in order to ‘enhance the marketability’ of their new Gripen fighter jets. But that’s possibly expected of anyone who grew up listening to ABBA’s “When I kissed the teacher” instead of focusing on education while in school.
Germany had a priority to evacuate ‘beer and wine’ during the takeover of Kabul by Taliban. However, one can try to make sense of the action as Oktoberfest was to commence in a month’s time or so.
And the Taliban is as trustworthy as the US Presidents, from Nixon till Biden. Even the British were left in the dark by the US about timings and pace of their withdrawal reported Steven Swinford of The Times while Biden ignored Boris Johnson’s attempts to speak on the phone for over 36+ hours claimed Ben Riley Smith of The Telegraph.
The US National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan said that President Joe Biden did not speak with any of his fellow world leaders in the aftermath of Kabul falling to the Taliban.
There is a great merit in the claim of Brookings that the Americans never understood Afghanistan like the Taliban did.
Can Europe be trusted with to handle the issue responsibly at all or Britain where the value of an Afghan life can be as low as GBP 104.7? The US special envoy for Haiti Daniel Foote resigned in protest over the deportation of Haitian migrants, and Afghanistan is a very far off place.
The Egyptian President Abdel Fattah Al-Sisi, a voice of sanity in the chaos, while mentioning Afghanistan, Pakistan, Libya and Egypt as countries whose people need to end conflicts said: “People in Islamic Countries should not expect the West to welcome them; They should instead solve the problems in their own countries.”
It would have been quite responsible of the 57 members of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation who could have played a more proactive role to harmoniously assimilate the refugees the Mid-East, Afghanistan or elsewhere within themselves because of the common religious and cultural affinity.
The silence of the OIC at a time when there is great risk that the progress made by Afghanistan in the last 20 years will be frittered away under the Taliban is also immensely confounding.
The signs are ominous. After almost 30 years, the Northern Alliance has opened the front against the Taliban again. The ex-Afghan Vice President and anti-Taliban Leader Amrullah Saleh claimed that “Afghanistan is too big for Pakistan to swallow and for Taliban to govern.”
For the U.S., that has declared Al Qaeda and ISIS as “terrorists” but not the Taliban, the victory of the Taliban over the US in Afghanistan will have serious local and wider implications.
And yet for many the fall of Kabul is not yet the end of American global power. Folks in Washington DC have started their usual pursuit of peace and fostering stability and development in Afghanistan once again.
But what’s the use? Political satire became obsolete when Henry Kissinger was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize as noted by Tom Lehrer long back.
We are living in times when the ability of leaders to effective communicate with each other is in serious doubt, not to mention the very ability of the leaders of the P-5 who are at the helm of affairs. It’s a Pandemonium.
One thing looks most certain. The Great Game in Afghanistan is like a Tumbling Dice on the Road to Ruin that predicts an ever-widening Non-Integrating Gap turning into a deep chasm which will take the country further away from the Functioning Core of the world. [IDN-InDepthNews — 24 September 2021]
Photo (from left to right): Jainendra Karn and Manish Uprety F.R.A.S.
IDN is the flagship agency of the Non-profit International Press Syndicate.
We believe in the free flow of information. Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International.